In reading the book How to be A Woman by British author
Caitlin Moran recently, I was struck by a statement she made regarding the
power of personal stories and how they lend credibility to greatly contested
subjects. Moran is a journalist who
offers her own experience of having an abortion long after giving birth to her
first two children. Much earlier, she’d
lost her first baby to stillbirth just before her wedding day. There seemed to be some equalization present
there – in my opinion – one lost by chance and the other by choice.
Moran talks about what happened in an unashamed manner that
I admire, mentioning a very private experience in a public forum with no excuse
necessary. She is strong enough to air
her own story so readers may stop to think of her circumstances as more real, more immediate, not speculative. Doing so helped lend to her credibility in my
mind. She wasn’t proselytizing on an
unknown topic. It was real for her.
Her words reinforced my belief that people don’t need
to justify themselves to anyone. A wise woman I know always says, “Your friends don’t need an
explanation, and your enemies won't believe you anyway.” Moran is confident of having made the right decision for her and drives the point home with her brave openness
about it.
That chapter of Moran's book took me back to the memory of a
gynecologist‘s waiting room several years ago. Patients were called to a separate “holding
area” to be weighed and have urine samples taken for pregnancy testing. Some eyes were downcast, most likely of those woman crossing their fingers for a negative result.
Others waited, nonplussed, dreading the cold steel
exam table, stirrups, speculum, and backless gown of a routine checkup. And some likely sat anxiously hoping for what
they considered good news of being pregnant.
A particularly joyous young lady was there giving
up her day's fluid intake to the sacrificial paper cup in hopes of her own positive reading. I, being at what is
considered “advanced maternal age,” unwillingly eavesdropped on the ensuing
glee at her test results. What a happy day for her and her partner -- if
he was, in fact, a willing participant in co-parenting. Good for them.
My husband and I married in our 30s, and I doubted whether
we’d ever have children. Throughout
childhood, and even into my teens and early 20s, I had always wanted to
eventually be a mom. I had taken it for
granted there would be babies in my future, not a life without kids. It just didn’t happen, and I'd accepted the facts. My life was happy, and I'd accomplished lots in my 37 or so years on the planet.
But I gave the woman a sidelong glance
as she gushed about her impending motherhood.
Young, inexperienced, over the moon with happiness, she had no idea what
other people around her were experiencing at that moment. Justifiably, she wasn’t thinking of anyone
else’s reason for being there – only the insular bubble of her own proverbial pee
stick. So, once again … good for her.
The first-time-mom-to-be had no concept of how her actions
were perceived by other women there.
Someone like me, who was there under the not-so-happy conditions of her
first exam post miscarriage. Our chances
at having a family grew even slimmer with the subtle creep of the clock on the
wall and the one in my body with its ever-dwindling yet life-sustaining hormone
levels.
I wasn’t really bitter toward her, then or now, but the
circumstances gave me pause to reflect on my own behavior. Maybe it isn’t always a good idea to put on
such an emotional display in public. I’m
not much on acting a certain way because of what other people think, but I was given
a new perspective on that October day in my now distant past.
In facing the death of a loved one, most people wish they
hadn’t left a word unspoken. They mentally
beg for another chance to tell that cherished family member or friend how much
they cared about them. There is no
opportunity to tell your unborn baby, especially at fetus stage, goodbye. If abortion protesters feel life begins at
conception, I wonder what they think of a fetus having a soul, a persona, an
identity. What about having a chance to
tell that “baby,” that person, goodbye?
So many words left unspoken there, especially with no physical presence
to make our baby a real person.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/atillavibes/ (via creative commons) |
My husband and I are now lucky enough to have a happy,
healthy almost six-year old son. He
completes and enlivens our family, so this chapter of our life book has a good ending. What happened at the doctor’s office that day
put me in the other person’s shoes, so to speak, where I could look at circumstances in a different light.
This is the first time I’ve opened up to anyone outside my immediate circle about losing that first pregnancy and do so only to encourage empathy. It’s not the same as sympathy and takes even less effort. I simply hope sharing my experience might urge someone else to think of how her/his actions, even good ones with no malice intended, might affect another person. Take a minute to think or act compassionately. I believe our world could greatly use more empathy and less judgment.
Powerful.
ReplyDeleteI lost 3. Had I not lost them my oldest would be 24. The youngest 19. Man... that makes me feel old. And I agree with you, it's the kind of thing we tend to keep to ourselves and not share outside a private circle. But I love how you linked it with judgements and being aware of our surroundings. One is giddy of an outcome that can destroy another's life... Very interesting take!
So glad you wrote this and shared it on S30+
Thanks for replying, Marie! Some topics are so taboo, it's hard to open up about them. And I can't imagine how a young woman would feel who had to have an abortion. Unfortunately, it seems they aren't embraced with any empathy.
DeleteThank you. I am 38, not married, and my chances of ever having kids gets smaller every day. So although I don't know the pain of miscarriage, I do know the pain of sitting in the office for your annual exam and annual lecture of how I better consider kids before I turn 40 while a much younger woman exalts over her first pregnancy. I don't grieve over a lost life, I grieve over a life I thought I would have by now. It hurts. But no one means for it to.
ReplyDeleteHi, Kristin! I was so sick of people talking about my age. One time a clueless young woman whom I didn't know even asked me, "Why'd you wait so long?" She had no idea how old I was, so I guess I looked like an old gray mare.
DeleteI would always try to remember the words of John Lennon instead ... "Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans." Good luck to you with your choices.
Wonderfully written. I'm working my way through "How to Be a Woman," and it's fascinating to read all these things that I would barely share with my closest friends, written in black and white for the world to read.
ReplyDeleteThank you for responding, Melanie! I was also surprised at how candid Moran was in her book, and I'm sure she got a lot of crap for it by reviewers. She's either brave or has skin as thick as an elephant. It would be so hard to put yourself out there like that.
DeleteThank you for sharing this piece at Studio30 Plus. I would not have found it otherwise. It's a powerful story and lesson.
ReplyDeleteCongratulations on your happy ending.
P.S.: You need to list a Twitter link for you here. I want to follow you, but don't see a link. Here's my acct if you want to follow. I will follow back:
ReplyDelete@NkdGirlinaDress
Thanks for your kind words! I get kind of "ranty" on Twitter (@onlyintheozarks) but can't remember if that's why I didn't put a link on Studio 30+ or not. lol
Delete